Fix: Android Alarm Volume Keeps Changing (Easy Steps)


Fix: Android Alarm Volume Keeps Changing (Easy Steps)

The phenomenon the place the loudness of a scheduled notification on a Google-operated cell working system unexpectedly fluctuates is a recurring difficulty for customers. This may manifest because the alert being quieter than anticipated, or inconsistently loud throughout completely different days and even completely different alerts on the identical day.

Constant and dependable auditory alerts are very important for well timed consciousness of scheduled occasions, treatment reminders, or necessary notifications. The advantages of a correctly functioning system embrace improved time administration, adherence to schedules, and a basic sense of reliability within the expertise used for every day group. Traditionally, sudden quantity changes have been reported throughout numerous Android variations and system producers, suggesting a multifaceted trigger.

The following sections will discover the potential causes behind these audio degree variations, the troubleshooting steps that may be employed to rectify the difficulty, and preventative measures to make sure reliable alert volumes on Android gadgets.

1. System Audio Settings

System audio settings on Android gadgets are a major determinant of alarm loudness, and misconfigurations or unintentional changes inside these settings continuously contribute to the perceived difficulty of unexpectedly fluctuating alarm volumes. The working system usually supplies impartial quantity controls for numerous audio streams, together with media, ringtone, and alarm sounds. If the designated alarm quantity is about too low inside the system’s audio mixer, the alarm could also be inaudible or simply missed, even when the alarm software itself is configured for optimum quantity.

Moreover, sure Android implementations characteristic a linked quantity management mechanism, the place changes to 1 audio stream (e.g., media quantity) can inadvertently have an effect on the alarm quantity. For instance, lowering the media quantity whereas listening to music may also decrease the alarm quantity with out the consumer’s express information. This interconnectedness, whereas supposed for consumer comfort, can result in unintended penalties, leading to missed alarms and a notion of erratic habits. Moreover, system updates or modifications can generally reset quantity settings to default values, negating beforehand configured preferences. A standard situation entails a consumer setting a desired alarm quantity, solely to seek out it reset to a decrease degree after a system replace, creating the impression that the alarm quantity spontaneously modifications.

In abstract, the system’s audio configuration serves because the foundational layer for alarm loudness. Person error, interconnected quantity controls, and unexpected system resets inside these settings are essential elements contributing to the noticed inconsistencies. Diligent examination and applicable configuration of the system audio settings are subsequently important for reaching predictable and dependable alarm habits on Android gadgets.

2. App Permissions

Android software permissions immediately govern an software’s entry to system assets and system functionalities. Within the context of inconsistent notification loudness, improperly configured or denied permissions can considerably impair an alarm software’s skill to set and keep a constant auditory output. As an illustration, if an alarm software lacks the permission to override the “Do Not Disturb” setting or modify system quantity, the alarm’s audio degree could also be suppressed or unexpectedly altered by the working system. The cause-and-effect relationship is easy: restricted permissions forestall the applying from absolutely executing its supposed operate, ensuing within the auditory notification failing to succeed in the specified quantity.

The “android alarm quantity retains altering” difficulty highlights the significance of fastidiously reviewing and granting applicable permissions to alarm purposes. An actual-life instance entails a consumer who put in a brand new alarm software however uncared for to grant it permission to “modify system settings.” Consequently, the applying couldn’t bypass the default quantity limits imposed by the working system, inflicting the alarm to sound at a persistently low degree, regardless of the consumer’s most popular quantity setting inside the software. One other situation entails the applying missing permission to run within the background with out restrictions. This may end up in the working system suspending the applying’s exercise, resulting in missed alarms or alarms that begin at a decreased quantity as a result of the applying has not but absolutely initialized its audio settings.

In conclusion, an intensive understanding of the connection between app permissions and the reliability of auditory notifications is essential for efficient troubleshooting. Customers should confirm that alarm purposes possess the mandatory permissions to operate accurately, notably these associated to system quantity management, background execution, and “Do Not Disturb” overrides. Failure to take action might end in inconsistent alarm volumes and a diminished consumer expertise. The proper permissions are important for sustaining a dependable alarm operate.

3. Do Not Disturb Mode

Do Not Disturb (DND) mode on Android gadgets is designed to silence notifications and calls, serving as a system-level mechanism to attenuate interruptions. Nevertheless, this characteristic interacts immediately with alert quantity configurations, continuously contributing to the difficulty of inconsistent alarm loudness. When DND is enabled, both manually or via a schedule, it could override application-specific quantity settings, lowering or fully muting alarm audio. This override happens regardless of the configured alarm quantity inside the alarm software itself. Subsequently, a consumer anticipating a loud alarm might discover it silenced or considerably decreased as a consequence of an energetic DND configuration. The significance of DND as a contributing issue to variable alarm quantity stems from its inherent design to suppress auditory alerts. Its presence necessitates cautious consideration when diagnosing problems with alarm quantity fluctuation.

A standard situation entails a consumer scheduling DND mode to activate throughout sleep hours. Whereas this successfully silences undesirable notifications, it could inadvertently silence or scale back the amount of any alarms scheduled throughout the identical interval. For instance, a consumer configures an alarm for 7:00 AM but additionally has DND scheduled from 11:00 PM to 7:30 AM. The alarm might sound at a considerably decrease quantity, or under no circumstances, as a result of DND is energetic. One other occasion entails exceptions inside DND. Whereas DND will be configured to permit calls or notifications from particular contacts, the system might not persistently apply these exceptions to alarms. Moreover, some Android implementations provide granular management over alarm habits inside DND, permitting customers to decide on whether or not alarms are silenced, decreased in quantity, or allowed to sound at full quantity. Nevertheless, the complexity of those settings can result in consumer error, the place the consumer unintentionally configures DND to suppress alarm audio.

In conclusion, DND mode’s integration with Android’s audio administration system immediately influences alert habits. Incorrectly configured or misunderstood DND settings are a frequent explanation for the issue below dialogue. A radical understanding of DND habits and its interplay with alarm configurations is thus important for reliably controlling and predicting alarm sound ranges. The potential for unintended alarm suppression necessitates cautious consumer configuration and system consciousness to make sure scheduled auditory alerts operate as anticipated.

See also  6+ Best Buffalo Bills Android Wallpapers for Fans!

4. Battery Optimization

Battery optimization options on Android gadgets, designed to increase battery life by managing software exercise within the background, can inadvertently contribute to fluctuations in alarm quantity. These options typically prohibit background processes, community entry, and CPU utilization for purposes deemed much less continuously used or resource-intensive. Alarm purposes, if subjected to aggressive battery optimization, might expertise decreased performance, together with an incapability to persistently keep desired quantity ranges. The working system’s try and preserve energy can subsequently immediately intrude with the dependable execution of alarm functionalities. The significance of battery optimization as a part of this difficulty stems from its ubiquitous presence on fashionable Android techniques and its potential to override user-configured alarm settings. For instance, an alarm software may be set to most quantity, however the working system’s battery optimization protocols might forestall it from reaching that degree, leading to a considerably quieter alarm. This can be a direct cause-and-effect relationship: battery optimization restricts background exercise, which in flip impairs the alarm software’s full performance.

An actual-life instance entails a consumer who persistently missed alarms as a consequence of low quantity. After investigating, it was found that the Android system had mechanically positioned the alarm software right into a “deep sleep” mode, limiting its background exercise. This mode restricted the applying’s skill to keep up its set quantity degree, notably after durations of inactivity. Disabling battery optimization for the alarm software resolved the difficulty, permitting it to operate as supposed. Additional sensible purposes of understanding this connection contain proactively excluding alarm purposes from battery optimization settings. Producers generally pre-install purposes with aggressive power-saving measures, necessitating handbook intervention to make sure correct alarm performance. This difficulty is extra pronounced in older Android variations or on gadgets with closely custom-made working techniques the place battery optimization is extra aggressively enforced.

In abstract, battery optimization methods on Android gadgets, whereas helpful for extending battery life, can negatively impression alarm reliability by limiting background exercise. This limitation can forestall alarm purposes from persistently reaching their desired quantity ranges. Understanding this connection is essential for troubleshooting inconsistent alarm quantity points. Guaranteeing that alarm purposes are exempt from battery optimization is a essential step in sustaining reliable alarm performance. The problem lies in balancing energy effectivity with the necessity for dependable and audible alerts, emphasizing the significance of consumer consciousness and customised configuration.

5. Alarm App Conflicts

The presence of a number of alarm purposes on an Android system can create a fancy interaction of settings and system useful resource rivalry, finally contributing to the issue of unpredictable alarm quantity ranges. This battle arises from the simultaneous makes an attempt of a number of purposes to manage the identical audio stream and system-level settings, resulting in inconsistencies and sudden habits.

  • Simultaneous Audio Stream Entry

    When a number of alarm purposes try and play sounds on the identical time or in shut succession, conflicts can come up in accessing the system’s audio stream. One software might interrupt or override the audio output of one other, leading to a sudden drop or change within the alarm quantity. Actual-world examples embrace customers who set up a brand new alarm software with out disabling the pre-installed system alarm, resulting in intermittent quantity inconsistencies as the 2 purposes compete for audio management.

  • Overlapping System Settings Modifications

    Alarm purposes typically modify system-level settings associated to quantity, “Do Not Disturb” mode, and background execution. When a number of purposes try to regulate these settings concurrently, conflicting directions will be despatched to the working system. As an illustration, one software may disable “Do Not Disturb” mode to make sure the alarm sounds, whereas one other concurrently allows it, resulting in an inconsistent alarm response. This creates a situation the place the efficient alarm quantity oscillates unpredictably.

  • Useful resource Rivalry and Background Processes

    Alarm purposes working within the background eat system assets, together with CPU time and reminiscence. When a number of purposes function concurrently, useful resource rivalry can happen, probably resulting in decreased efficiency or sudden habits. The impression on alarm quantity can manifest as delayed alarm activation or a brief discount in audio output because the system struggles to allocate assets successfully. The competitors for system assets may cause a number of of the apps to have their quantity ranges inadvertently throttled.

  • Scheduled Alarm Collisions

    If a number of alarm purposes are scheduled to set off alarms at or close to the identical time, collisions can happen. One software’s alarm might preempt or intrude with one other, leading to missed alarms or a sudden, sudden change in quantity. Moreover, the system’s try and handle these simultaneous occasions may end up in inconsistencies, resulting in an unreliable and unpredictable alarm expertise. Resolving such collisions typically necessitates disabling or uninstalling redundant alarm purposes.

In abstract, “Alarm App Conflicts” current a multifaceted problem in sustaining constant alarm quantity. The interaction of simultaneous audio stream entry makes an attempt, overlapping system setting modifications, useful resource rivalry, and scheduled alarm collisions contributes to the difficulty of sudden quantity fluctuations. Efficient administration requires cautious consideration of the quantity and sort of alarm purposes put in, in addition to their particular person settings and useful resource utilization. Eradicating redundant purposes and guaranteeing correct configuration are essential steps in mitigating these conflicts and guaranteeing reliable alarm habits.

6. Accessibility Options

Accessibility options on Android gadgets are designed to reinforce the consumer expertise for people with numerous disabilities. These options, supposed to offer custom-made help, can inadvertently affect system-level settings like quantity management, probably contributing to the difficulty of fluctuating notification ranges. A radical understanding of how these options work together with alarm functionalities is important to mitigating such issues.

  • Quantity Adjustment Customizations

    Accessibility settings typically permit customers to fine-tune quantity ranges past the usual system settings. For instance, some options allow amplification of particular audio frequencies to help customers with listening to impairments. Whereas helpful, these customizations can override default alarm quantity configurations, resulting in sudden decreases or will increase in auditory output. If a consumer inadvertently units an especially low amplification degree for a selected frequency vary utilized by the alarm, the alarm might turn into just about inaudible. This can be a real-world manifestation of the complicated interplay between accessibility settings and alarm functionalities.

  • Notification Customization Conflicts

    Sure accessibility companies provide superior notification customization choices, equivalent to flashing the system’s digital camera or displaying persistent on-screen alerts. When a number of accessibility companies are energetic, conflicts can come up in how these notifications are introduced, together with their related quantity ranges. As an illustration, one service may try and suppress audio notifications to prioritize visible alerts, whereas one other service makes an attempt to maximise quantity. This battle ends in inconsistent and unpredictable notification volumes, affecting alarm audibility.

  • Textual content-to-Speech Interactions

    Textual content-to-Speech (TTS) performance, used to learn on-screen textual content aloud, can affect alarm habits if the alarm software depends on TTS for audio output. If the TTS engine is configured with a low quantity degree or is experiencing technical points, the alarm sound could also be muted or distorted. Moreover, system updates or TTS engine modifications can alter the default quantity settings, resulting in sudden modifications in alarm audibility. Thus, TTS settings can not directly impression alarm efficiency.

  • Listening to Support Compatibility (HAC)

    Units designated as Listening to Support Suitable (HAC) endure particular testing and modifications to attenuate interference with listening to aids. Nevertheless, these modifications also can have an effect on alarm quantity ranges. In some circumstances, enabling HAC mode may inadvertently scale back the utmost quantity output of the alarm to keep away from suggestions or distortion when used with listening to aids. A setting supposed to reinforce audio readability for listening to help customers can unexpectedly suppress alarm audibility for different customers, demonstrating a possible adverse consequence of accessibility settings.

See also  7+ Fixes: Android Can't Make Calls - Easy Guide!

In abstract, accessibility options on Android gadgets, whereas important for inclusivity, can introduce complexities within the configuration and administration of audio alerts. The intricate interaction between quantity adjustment customizations, notification customization conflicts, Textual content-to-Speech interactions, and Listening to Support Compatibility settings contributes to the noticed inconsistencies in alert habits. Understanding these interdependencies is significant for customers looking for to troubleshoot and optimize the reliability of alarms and different essential notifications. The problem lies in balancing the necessity for personalised accessibility help with the reassurance of reliable system performance.

7. Software program Bugs

Software program anomalies inside the Android working system can manifest as unpredictable system habits, immediately contributing to the difficulty of inconsistent alarm quantity ranges. These anomalies, originating from coding errors or unexpected interactions between software program parts, disrupt anticipated system capabilities, probably compromising the reliability of scheduled notifications.

  • Audio Driver Malfunctions

    Defects inside audio driver software program may end up in inconsistent audio output ranges. These malfunctions might trigger the alarm quantity to fluctuate unexpectedly, no matter user-defined settings. An actual-world instance is a coding error that causes the motive force to intermittently default to a decrease quantity setting throughout alarm playback, overriding the configured degree. That is notably related after system updates or driver revisions.

  • API Inconsistencies

    Utility Programming Interface (API) discrepancies can introduce inconsistencies in how alarm purposes work together with the working system’s quantity management mechanisms. If an API operate chargeable for setting the alarm quantity comprises a bug, the alarm software might fail to persistently set up the supposed audio degree. For instance, a poorly applied API name might trigger the system to sporadically ignore the amount setting offered by the alarm software.

  • Concurrency Points

    Concurrency points, arising from a number of software program processes making an attempt to entry the identical system useful resource concurrently, can result in unpredictable alarm quantity habits. If an alarm software makes an attempt to set the amount similtaneously one other course of, equivalent to a media participant, the ensuing quantity degree could also be inconsistent or suppressed. This may manifest because the alarm sounding at a considerably decrease quantity than anticipated as a consequence of rivalry for audio assets.

  • Working System Glitches

    Elementary flaws inside the Android working system itself can precipitate alarm quantity inconsistencies. These glitches, which will be triggered by particular system states or {hardware} configurations, might trigger the system to disregard or misread the alarm software’s quantity settings. A demonstrable occasion is a reminiscence leak that causes system instability and inconsistent quantity management after prolonged durations of system uptime, resulting in intermittent alarm loudness variations.

Software program bugs are an intrinsic a part of complicated working techniques like Android. Their manifestations, starting from audio driver malfunctions to system-level glitches, immediately impression the dependability of essential notifications. Addressing the difficulty of inconsistent alarm quantity necessitates a concentrate on resolving underlying software program defects via rigorous testing, updates, and debugging. Figuring out the presence of those anomalies is paramount to reaching the dependable, predictable performance customers count on.

8. {Hardware} Points

{Hardware} malfunctions inside an Android system signify a big potential explanation for inconsistent alarm quantity. Bodily parts chargeable for audio output, such because the speaker or amplifier, are vulnerable to degradation or harm, immediately impacting the flexibility to supply constant sound ranges. When {hardware} fails to function inside specified parameters, the ensuing auditory output will be erratic and unpredictable, resulting in cases the place the notification quantity unexpectedly fluctuates. The significance of {hardware} integrity within the context of this downside stems from the truth that software program configurations are rendered ineffective if the underlying {hardware} is incapable of precisely reproducing the supposed audio sign. For instance, a broken speaker might produce distorted or muffled sound, whatever the alarm quantity setting inside the working system.

Actual-world situations illustrating this connection embrace cases the place bodily harm to the speaker diaphragm ends in inconsistent vibration and sound output. The speaker may operate usually at sure frequencies however fail to breed others, resulting in alarms which are intermittently loud or quiet. Moreover, inside amplifier failures may cause the audio sign to be attenuated, leading to persistently low alarm volumes. This typically manifests after a drop or impression to the system. Sensible purposes of understanding this hardware-software interplay contain diagnostic procedures, equivalent to testing the speaker with recognized audio indicators at numerous frequencies to establish potential failures. Ruling out {hardware} as a possible trigger is important earlier than focusing solely on software-related points. In circumstances of {hardware} malfunction, the mandatory decision entails part restore or substitute.

In abstract, {hardware} integrity is a essential consider guaranteeing constant alarm quantity on Android gadgets. Bodily harm or degradation to audio parts can immediately impede the correct replica of audio indicators, rendering software program configurations ineffective. A radical understanding of this hardware-software relationship, coupled with diagnostic procedures to establish potential part failures, is important for precisely troubleshooting and resolving problems with fluctuating notification quantity. The problem lies in differentiating between software-related anomalies and underlying {hardware} malfunctions, necessitating a complete diagnostic strategy to make sure reliable alarm performance.

9. Scheduled Routines

Automated sequences of actions triggered by particular occasions or instances, “Scheduled Routines,” current a possible supply of inconsistency in alarm quantity. These routines, configurable inside purposes like Google Assistant or IFTTT, typically embrace actions that immediately or not directly affect system quantity settings. The execution of a routine may inadvertently alter the alarm quantity, both via a pre-programmed instruction or as a aspect impact of one other motion. This interplay contributes to the issue of alarm quantity unexpectedly altering. The significance of “Scheduled Routines” as a part of this difficulty stems from their capability to override user-configured alarm settings with out express notification. For instance, a routine designed to decrease media quantity at night time might inadvertently have an effect on alarm quantity if the system hyperlinks these audio streams. This underscores the necessity for cautious configuration and consciousness of routine actions.

See also  7+ Tips: Set SMS Center Number on Android

Take into account a situation the place a consumer units up a routine to play calming sounds earlier than bedtime. The routine contains an motion that reduces media quantity to a low degree. If the Android system treats alarm quantity as a subset of media quantity, the next alarm may sound on the identical decreased degree, regardless of the alarm software’s configured quantity setting. One other sensible software entails analyzing routines for conflicting directions. A routine might set the alarm quantity to a selected degree at a specific time, overriding the consumer’s most popular setting. Such occurrences spotlight the necessity to audit routine configurations to establish and get rid of unintended quantity changes. Moreover, some routines might incorporate actions that have an effect on “Do Not Disturb” mode, which, as beforehand mentioned, immediately impacts alarm audibility. A routine that mechanically allows “Do Not Disturb” at night time, with out correct exceptions for alarms, will inevitably suppress alarm quantity.

In abstract, “Scheduled Routines” introduce a layer of complexity in managing alarm quantity as a consequence of their capability to automate system-level actions that have an effect on audio output. A cautious examination of routine configurations and their interactions with system settings is important for troubleshooting and resolving cases of sudden alarm quantity modifications. The problem lies in sustaining the comfort of automated routines whereas guaranteeing the constant and dependable operation of important capabilities like alarms. Subsequently, customers should perceive and meticulously configure their routines to keep away from unintended alterations to system audio settings and guarantee the correct functioning of alarms.

Incessantly Requested Questions

The next addresses generally encountered inquiries concerning the phenomenon of fluctuating alert loudness on gadgets working below the Android OS.

Query 1: What are the first elements contributing to fluctuating auditory alert loudness on gadgets working the Android working system?

A number of parts affect alert quantity consistency. These embody system audio settings, software permissions, Do Not Disturb configurations, battery optimization protocols, conflicts between alert purposes, accessibility options, defects inside the software program, anomalies inside the {hardware}, and scheduled routines.

Query 2: How does the Do Not Disturb operate have an effect on the auditory alert quantity?

The Do Not Disturb mode has the capability to override the configurations particular to an software, ensuing within the diminution or full muting of alarm sounds. This operate necessitates cautious consideration in the course of the diagnostic course of regarding variations in alert quantity.

Query 3: Why is it essential to confirm software permissions when addressing alert quantity inconsistencies?

Utility permissions dictate an software’s capability to entry assets and system functionalities. Insufficient permissions can impede an alert purposes functionality to determine and maintain constant auditory outputs.

Query 4: To what extent do system audio settings impression alert quantity?

System audio configurations represent a foundational layer for alert loudness. Misconfigurations and inadvertent changes in these settings continuously contribute to perceived points in alert quantity fluctuations.

Query 5: How do battery optimization options affect auditory alert habits?

Battery optimization measures can prohibit background processes, which, in flip, interferes with an alert purposes skill to maintain its designated quantity degree. Exemption of alert purposes from battery optimization protocols is essential for sustaining constant efficiency.

Query 6: Can a number of alert purposes result in inconsistencies in alert quantity?

The co-existence of a number of alert purposes might precipitate useful resource rivalry and settings conflicts, culminating in inconsistencies in alert quantity as purposes concurrently search to handle equivalent system assets.

Comprehension of those parts is significant for successfully resolving alert quantity irregularities. Constant upkeep of configuration settings and system evaluation are essential for the decision of this difficulty.

The following part will discover focused approaches for resolving alert quantity inconsistencies, detailing step-by-step troubleshooting methodologies to optimize system performance.

Mitigating Erratic Auditory Notification Ranges

The next suggestions provide steerage for addressing inconsistent auditory notification loudness on Android gadgets. Adherence to those steps ought to promote extra predictable and dependable alert habits.

Tip 1: Carry out a meticulous assessment of system audio configurations. Be certain that the devoted alert quantity management is about to an sufficient degree. Confirm that the media quantity is independently managed and doesn’t inadvertently affect the alert quantity.

Tip 2: Validate software permissions for the particular alert software. The permission to switch system settings is important for the applying to override default quantity limitations. Allow background execution permissions to stop the working system from suspending the applying.

Tip 3: Study Do Not Disturb settings for scheduled activations. Confirm that the alert software is exempted from Do Not Disturb mode or that the mode is configured to permit alert sounds on the desired quantity.

Tip 4: Assess battery optimization settings for the alert software. Exempt the applying from battery saving measures to stop restrictions on background exercise that will restrict performance.

Tip 5: Reduce the variety of alert purposes put in on the system. A number of purposes making an attempt to manage the identical system assets can result in conflicts and inconsistent habits. Uninstall redundant purposes to scale back potential interference.

Tip 6: Analyze accessibility characteristic configurations. Be aware of quantity customizations or notification settings that will inadvertently have an effect on alert output. Check with accessibility options disabled to isolate potential conflicts.

Tip 7: Make sure the system is working the newest software program updates. Updates typically embrace bug fixes and efficiency enhancements that may deal with underlying points contributing to inconsistent alert volumes.

Tip 8: Check the system’s {hardware} parts, particularly the speaker, to rule out bodily harm or degradation. Use diagnostic instruments or recognized audio indicators to evaluate the speaker’s efficiency at numerous frequencies.

Persistently making use of these suggestions ought to reduce cases of unpredictable auditory notification loudness. Proactive administration of system settings, software configurations, and {hardware} evaluation promotes a extra steady and dependable alert expertise.

The ultimate part will provide concluding remarks and spotlight the significance of dependable auditory alerts.

Conclusion

The previous evaluation elucidated the multifarious causes of the “android alarm quantity retains altering” difficulty. From system settings and app permissions to software program anomalies and {hardware} malfunctions, quite a few elements can contribute to the inconsistency of auditory notifications. Efficient decision necessitates a complete understanding of those parts and a scientific strategy to troubleshooting, as unpredictable alerts can disrupt schedules and compromise well timed consciousness.

Reliable auditory notifications are essential for efficient time administration and adherence to essential schedules. Constant vigilance in sustaining system configurations, assessing app behaviors, and monitoring {hardware} efficiency is crucial for mitigating the potential disruptions attributable to erratic alert habits. Ongoing refinement and updates to Android OS and associated purposes stay very important for guaranteeing dependable and predictable alarm performance, thereby enhancing the consumer expertise.

Leave a Comment