8+ Must-Read Apples Never Fall Book Review [Spoiler-Free!]


8+ Must-Read Apples Never Fall Book Review [Spoiler-Free!]

The evaluation of evaluative texts pertaining to Liane Moriarty’s novel, Apples By no means Fall, supplies important commentary and evaluation of the work. This encompasses summaries, important interpretations, and reader reactions printed in varied media, providing views on the narrative, characters, and themes. For instance, a broadcast critique would possibly analyze the e-book’s exploration of household dynamics or the effectiveness of its suspense components.

Examination of those critiques provides quite a few advantages. It permits potential readers to gauge whether or not the novel aligns with their preferences earlier than investing time in studying it. Critiques can spotlight strengths and weaknesses of the novel, sparking dialogue and a deeper understanding of the creator’s intent and execution. Traditionally, e-book opinions have performed a major position in shaping literary reception and influencing readership choices.

Subsequent sections will delve into widespread themes and recurring critiques discovered inside the evaluation of the novel. We’ll additional study the important reception, exploring each constructive and destructive elements steadily addressed in evaluations of the e-book. Lastly, the affect of those evaluations on reader engagement and total notion of the work shall be thought of.

1. Plot abstract

Plot abstract is a foundational factor inside an evaluation of evaluative texts. A transparent and concise plot abstract supplies context for understanding subsequent important commentary. Within the case of Liane Moriarty’s Apples By no means Fall, the abstract outlines the disappearance of Pleasure Delaney and the suspicion that falls upon her husband, Stan, whereas additionally detailing the complicated relationships inside the Delaney household. This fundamental understanding of the narrative’s core battle is crucial earlier than analyzing reviewers’ opinions on the pacing, character improvement, or thematic resonance of the novel. For example, a evaluation criticizing the believability of Stan’s conduct requires the reader to know the preliminary setup: that he’s a major suspect in his spouse’s disappearance. With out this foundational plot data, the critique turns into indifferent and fewer significant. The absence of a transparent plot abstract would undermine the effectiveness of any subsequent dialogue.

The inclusion of a plot synopsis inside the important evaluation of Apples By no means Fall permits readers to contextualize observations relating to narrative construction or pacing. If a evaluation discusses the novel’s gradual burn method, the supplied abstract permits one to attach that analysis to particular occasions and factors of rising motion inside the total storyline. Furthermore, highlighting key plot factors inside the evaluation permits readers to grasp the inspiration on which the opinions are primarily based, bettering readability. Completely different opinions could emphasize specific plot factors or provide various interpretations of their significance. For instance, some opinions would possibly give attention to the tennis academy subplot, whereas others prioritize the small print surrounding Pleasure’s disappearance. A robust evaluation presents a plot abstract as an goal basis for the subjective evaluation that follows.

In abstract, the plot abstract serves as an indispensable element of any evaluation of Apples By no means Fall. It acts as a shared baseline of understanding, permitting readers to understand the context for important evaluation of the novel’s characters, themes, or stylistic selections. Potential challenges embody guaranteeing the plot abstract is concise but complete, avoiding spoilers whereas precisely representing the core narrative. Integrating a well-crafted abstract ensures that the critique stays accessible and related to a large viewers, thereby enhancing understanding of each the plot and important reception.

2. Character evaluation

Character evaluation varieties a important element of evaluative texts discussing Liane Moriarty’s Apples By no means Fall. Opinions routinely dissect the personalities, motivations, and improvement arcs of key figures, influencing the general notion of the novel’s advantage and effectiveness.

  • Delaney Household Dynamics

    Character evaluation inside Apples By no means Fall e-book opinions focuses on the complicated relationships among the many Delaney members of the family: Stan, Pleasure, Amy, Troy, Brooke, and Logan. Assessments scrutinize how these interactions affect the narrative, drive the plot, and reveal underlying themes of household secrets and techniques, resentments, and loyalties. For example, opinions usually consider the effectiveness of Moriartys depiction of sibling rivalry or the plausibility of Stan and Joys marital struggles. In impact, the success of the novel rests closely on convincing portrayals of those people and their interactions.

  • Stan Delaney as a Suspect

    A major aspect of character evaluation facilities on Stan Delaney, Joys husband and a main suspect in her disappearance. Opinions usually study whether or not his portrayal successfully generates suspense and ambiguity. Assessments steadily discover the nuances of his character, weighing his seemingly aloof demeanor in opposition to hints of a darker aspect. This scrutiny influences the reader’s notion of the thriller on the coronary heart of the narrative; a compelling characterization of Stan is crucial for sustaining the reader’s engagement and funding.

  • Pleasure Delaney’s Perspective

    Character opinions deal with the character of Pleasure Delaney, contemplating her position as a mom, spouse, and particular person grappling with a way of misplaced id. These analyses assess how successfully Moriarty portrays Pleasure’s internal life, wishes, and vulnerabilities. The opinions take into account how sympathetic and comprehensible Pleasure’s character is, which is essential given her standing because the lacking individual whose destiny drives the plot. A well-developed and nuanced portrayal of Pleasure enhances the novel’s emotional affect and thematic exploration.

  • Supporting Characters’ Impression

    Past the core household, assessments study the affect of supporting characters equivalent to Savannah, and the varied peripheral people who work together with the Delaneys. Opinions could assess the contribution of Savannah to the plot’s complexity, or whether or not they perform primarily as plot gadgets or present significant insights into the principle characters and their conditions. The effectiveness of those characters’ contributions is usually evaluated by way of how they improve or detract from the overarching narrative.

These sides of character evaluation are integral to understanding the important response to Apples By no means Fall. The depth, complexity, and believability of the characters straight affect how readers and critics understand the novel’s success in exploring themes of household, marriage, and secrets and techniques. Finally, critiques of Apples By no means Fall persistently display the essential position of character improvement in shaping a novel’s total affect and reader reception.

3. Thematic components

The thematic parts of Apples By no means Fall represent an important side of its important evaluation. Evaluate evaluations steadily deal with recurring motifs and conceptual explorations, impacting the general judgment of the novel’s depth and resonance.

  • Household Dynamics and Dysfunctions

    The first theme of household, significantly its inherent dysfunctions, receives vital consideration within the opinions. Evaluation focuses on the portrayal of sibling rivalry, parental expectations, and the load of secrets and techniques inside the Delaney household. Reviewers usually analyze how the novel explores the strain between familial loyalty and particular person wishes, citing examples of how these dynamics contribute to the general suspense of the narrative. The credibility and emotional affect of those relationships kind a cornerstone of many critiques.

  • Marriage and Lengthy-Time period Relationships

    The establishment of marriage, particularly the complexities and challenges confronted by long-term companions, is one other prevalent thematic factor in opinions. The connection between Stan and Pleasure Delaney is scrutinized for its portrayal of complacency, resentment, and the potential for hidden truths. Evaluations usually deal with the novel’s depiction of communication breakdowns and the erosion of intimacy over time, analyzing whether or not the portrayal is reasonable and contributes to the central thriller.

  • Look vs. Actuality

    Opinions generally spotlight the theme of misleading appearances inside Apples By no means Fall. The Delaney household, seemingly profitable and comfortable from the surface, harbors deep-seated points and secrets and techniques. Opinions consider how successfully the novel unveils the disparity between the household’s public picture and their non-public struggles. Critics take into account how this thematic factor contributes to the suspenseful ambiance and the questioning of characters’ motives.

  • The Impression of the Previous

    The lingering affect of previous occasions on present-day relationships and choices is a recurring theme famous in lots of critiques. The novel explores how previous traumas and unresolved conflicts proceed to form the Delaney household’s dynamics. Opinions analyze how successfully Moriarty weaves these previous experiences into the current narrative, and whether or not the exploration of previous secrets and techniques contributes to a better understanding of the characters’ actions and motivations.

See also  8+ Crisp Strongbow Gold Apple Cider: Refreshing & Gold!

These thematic analyses considerably affect the evaluations of Apples By no means Fall. The reviewers’ evaluation of how successfully the novel explores these core themes usually determines the general notion of its literary advantage and its potential to resonate with readers. A robust engagement with these themes contributes to a deeper and extra significant studying expertise, as mirrored within the important response.

4. Important reception

Important reception constitutes an integral part inside any complete evaluation of Apples By no means Fall. Evaluative texts discussing the novel invariably reference its reception by skilled reviewers and literary critics. This encompasses a broad vary of opinions and assessments relating to its narrative construction, character improvement, thematic depth, and total literary advantage. Constructive assessments could spotlight the novel’s suspenseful plot and relatable characters, whereas destructive critiques could give attention to pacing points or perceived predictability of plot twists. The general important reception influences the general public notion of the novel, which subsequently impacts gross sales and readership.

The important response to Apples By no means Fall straight shapes its fame inside the literary panorama. For instance, a evaluation printed in a revered newspaper or literary journal holds substantial affect over readers and bookstore consumers. Favorable opinions usually result in elevated visibility and constructive word-of-mouth, contributing to increased gross sales and a broader readership. Conversely, predominantly destructive opinions can discourage potential readers and diminish the novel’s business success. Understanding the vary of opinions expressed in evaluative texts supplies perception into the novel’s strengths and weaknesses, as recognized by literary specialists. Evaluation of those opinions reveals prevailing themes and important arguments surrounding the novel. The important reception serves as a lens by which the novel is interpreted and finally understood by a wider viewers.

In abstract, important reception performs a pivotal position in shaping the general notion of Apples By no means Fall. By fastidiously analyzing and analyzing the opinions printed by literary critics and journals, a extra thorough understanding of the novel’s deserves and shortcomings emerges. This understanding, in flip, contributes to a extra knowledgeable analysis of the novel’s place inside modern literature and its affect on readers. Discrepancies between important acclaim and reader response current ongoing challenges in assessing literary advantage, underscoring the complexity of evaluating artistic works.

5. Reader response

Reader response, because it pertains to evaluative texts regarding Apples By no means Fall, displays the varied and subjective reactions of people who’ve engaged with the novel. These responses, usually distinct from formal important analyses, provide beneficial insights into the e-book’s affect on its viewers.

  • Emotional Connection

    Particular person readers steadily categorical their emotional connection to the characters and conditions depicted in Apples By no means Fall. These reactions, starting from empathy for Pleasure Delaney’s plight to frustration with the sibling dynamics, form their total studying expertise. On-line boards and e-book evaluation platforms usually host discussions the place readers share their private emotions and interpretations, offering a wealthy tapestry of subjective views. For instance, some could discover the novel deeply shifting on account of its portrayal of marital struggles, whereas others could also be extra engaged by the suspenseful components of the plot.

  • Identification with Themes

    Reader response usually highlights the diploma to which people establish with the thematic components explored in Apples By no means Fall. Themes equivalent to household dysfunction, the challenges of growing older, and the load of secrets and techniques resonate otherwise with varied readers primarily based on their private experiences. A reader who has skilled related household tensions would possibly provide a very insightful interpretation of the Delaney household dynamics, whereas somebody with a special background could discover it much less compelling. This various diploma of identification influences their evaluation of the novel’s authenticity and relevance.

  • Critique of Narrative Parts

    Past emotional responses and thematic connections, readers steadily provide critiques of particular narrative components inside Apples By no means Fall. These feedback could deal with elements equivalent to pacing, character improvement, or the believability of the plot. On-line opinions usually embody discussions about whether or not the suspense is successfully maintained all through the novel, or whether or not sure characters’ actions appear believable. Such suggestions, whereas subjective, supplies beneficial insights into the novel’s strengths and weaknesses from the attitude of its supposed viewers.

  • Impression on E book Suggestion

    Reader responses straight affect e-book suggestions and word-of-mouth advertising and marketing for Apples By no means Fall. Constructive opinions and enthusiastic suggestions from readers usually result in elevated gross sales and a wider readership. Conversely, destructive suggestions can deter potential readers from participating with the novel. The combination of reader responses, subsequently, performs a major position in shaping the general notion and business success of the work. Analyzing these responses provides a direct understanding of the novel’s affect on its audience.

In summation, analyzing reader responses to Apples By no means Fall provides a multifaceted understanding of the novel’s affect past the realm of formal important evaluation. These reactions, encompassing emotional connections, thematic identification, narrative critiques, and impacts on suggestions, present important context for evaluating the novel’s total reception and enduring enchantment.

6. Writing model

The evaluation of writing model varieties an integral a part of any complete evaluation of evaluative texts targeted on Apples By no means Fall. Opinions of the novel steadily deal with Moriarty’s distinctive prose, narrative voice, and structural selections, influencing the general important reception.

See also  6+ Calories: Yellow Delicious Apple Guide & Facts

  • Tempo and Construction

    Evaluations usually give attention to Moriarty’s pacing, particularly how successfully the novel builds suspense. Some opinions reward the deliberate unfolding of secrets and techniques, contributing to a slow-burn thriller. Conversely, different critiques counsel that the pacing lags at sure factors, hindering reader engagement. The construction, encompassing a number of views and timelines, additionally garners consideration. Opinions usually study how the shifting viewpoints and non-linear narrative contribute to, or detract from, the general cohesiveness and affect of the story.

  • Dialogue and Character Voice

    The standard and realism of the dialogue are generally scrutinized in opinions. Critics usually assess whether or not the conversations between characters really feel genuine and reveal their personalities successfully. Particular consideration is paid to the distinct voice given to every character, contributing to their individuality and credibility. Efficient dialogue is usually lauded for enhancing the emotional affect of scenes and revealing underlying tensions inside the Delaney household.

  • Descriptive Language and Imagery

    Evaluations steadily deal with Moriarty’s use of descriptive language and imagery. Opinions could analyze the vividness and effectiveness of her descriptions in setting the scene and creating ambiance. Critics usually discover how the creator’s phrase selections contribute to the general tone and temper of the novel. The usage of sensory particulars and figurative language is usually examined for its potential to boost the reader’s immersion within the story.

  • Narrative Perspective and Tone

    The selection of narrative perspective and the general tone adopted by Moriarty are sometimes mentioned in opinions. Critics consider the affect of a third-person restricted perspective, exploring the way it shapes the reader’s understanding of the characters and occasions. The tone, usually described as a mix of suspenseful and home, is analyzed for its effectiveness in making a compelling studying expertise. Opinions usually take into account how the narrative perspective and tone contribute to the general thematic exploration of household secrets and techniques and hidden truths.

In abstract, the writing model employed in Apples By no means Fall is a key factor in shaping its important reception. The novel’s pacing, dialogue, descriptive language, and narrative perspective all contribute to the general studying expertise, and their effectiveness is steadily assessed in opinions. By analyzing these components, critics and readers alike acquire a deeper understanding of Moriarty’s craft and the novel’s affect.

7. Pacing evaluation

The analysis of pacing constitutes a major dimension inside the important reception of Liane Moriarty’s Apples By no means Fall. Opinions steadily scrutinize the novel’s tempo and the distribution of narrative occasions, straight influencing the general judgment of its effectiveness.

  • Preliminary Engagement and Hook

    The effectiveness of the novel’s opening chapters in capturing the reader’s consideration is an important side of pacing evaluation. Opinions usually analyze whether or not the preliminary setup, introducing the Delaney household and the thriller of Pleasure’s disappearance, is sufficiently compelling to attract readers into the story. The absence of a powerful preliminary hook can result in reader disengagement, negatively impacting the general reception. For example, opinions usually point out if the premise of the story is participating to the readers or if it takes some time for them to get into it.

  • Distribution of Suspense and Reveals

    Opinions generally deal with the stability between suspenseful moments and the gradual unveiling of clues and plot twists. The distribution of those components all through the novel is assessed for its potential to keep up reader curiosity with out sacrificing narrative coherence. Pacing assessments take into account whether or not the novel reveals an excessive amount of too quickly, thereby diminishing the suspense, or if it withholds data for too lengthy, resulting in reader frustration. Opinions could embody elements like if the reveals are spaced out properly or if the suspence is maintained within the story.

  • Tempo of Subplots and Character Improvement

    Evaluations usually scrutinize the pacing of subplots and character improvement arcs inside Apples By no means Fall. Opinions analyze whether or not these secondary storylines and character evolutions contribute meaningfully to the central thriller or detract from its momentum. Assessments take into account whether or not sure subplots are resolved too shortly or if others linger for too lengthy, disrupting the general rhythm of the narrative. It’s assessed to see if the character improvement arcs play a component within the story and the way the plot flows.

  • Climax and Decision

    The pacing of the novel’s climax and determination receives specific consideration in opinions. Assessments consider whether or not the climax feels earned and satisfying, or if it rushes or feels anticlimactic. The pace and readability with which the central thriller is resolved are additionally scrutinized. A well-paced decision supplies closure and leaves a long-lasting impression on the reader, whereas a poorly paced one can diminish the general affect of the novel. Opinions could embody opinions on the affect the climax and determination has on the readers.

In conclusion, pacing evaluation is a pivotal element of Apples By no means Fall e-book opinions. It straight influences perceptions of the novel’s total effectiveness and its potential to keep up reader engagement. Various opinions on the pacing of plot reveals and character improvement could finally contribute to a variety of reader interpretations and total important reception.

8. Narrative construction

Narrative construction, encompassing components equivalent to plot group, perspective, and the sequencing of occasions, exerts a major affect on important analyses of Liane Moriarty’s Apples By no means Fall. The style during which the story is instructed straight shapes readers’ and critics’ interpretations, thereby impacting total evaluations of the novel.

  • A number of Views

    Apples By no means Fall employs a number of views, shifting viewpoints among the many Delaney members of the family. This construction influences opinions by prompting evaluation of its effectiveness in creating suspense, revealing character motivations, and exploring the complicated dynamics of the household. Opinions usually take into account whether or not the alternating views improve or detract from the readability and emotional affect of the narrative. For example, critics could analyze how the shifting views contribute to a nuanced understanding of Stan’s character, or in the event that they create confusion relating to the central thriller.

  • Non-Linear Timeline

    The novel employs a non-linear timeline, interweaving present-day occasions with flashbacks to earlier durations within the Delaney household’s historical past. This construction influences e-book opinions by prompting consideration of its affect on the unfolding of the plot and the revelation of secrets and techniques. Opinions could assess whether or not the flashbacks successfully construct suspense and supply context for present occasions, or in the event that they disrupt the narrative circulation and diminish reader engagement. Particularly, reviewers can study how these flashbacks assist or hinder a reader’s potential to piece collectively the occasions of the previous and current, finally influencing their engagement.

  • Framing Machine

    The narrative construction usually makes use of a framing system, such because the disappearance of Pleasure Delaney, to contextualize the unfolding household drama. This system influences opinions by prompting an analysis of its effectiveness in producing suspense and driving the plot ahead. Critics could assess whether or not the framing system efficiently creates a way of thriller and anticipation, or if it feels contrived or detracts from the general realism of the story. How properly the framing system is dealt with is necessary as a result of it’s the factor that holds the reader’s consideration to the story.

  • Episodic Construction

    The narrative unfolds in an episodic method, specializing in particular occasions or durations within the Delaney household’s life. This construction influences opinions by prompting evaluation of its contribution to character improvement and thematic exploration. Opinions could take into account whether or not every episode successfully reveals new sides of the characters or explores underlying themes of household secrets and techniques and resentments. Critics could consider how properly every portion of the story provides to the general plot and the way all the particular person narratives tie right into a compelling story for the reader.

See also  6+ Facts: Can Apples Clean Your Teeth & Whiten?

These structural components collectively form the studying expertise and, consequently, the evaluative responses present in Apples By no means Fall e-book opinions. Evaluation of how these selections affect narrative circulation, character improvement, and thematic resonance varieties an important side of understanding the novel’s important reception. The general success of the narrative design, by way of protecting the reader engaged, is the important thing to total opinions of the story.

Continuously Requested Questions About Analyses of Apples By no means Fall

The next addresses widespread inquiries relating to important and reader evaluations of Liane Moriarty’s novel. These questions goal to supply readability on varied elements of the novel’s reception and evaluation.

Query 1: What basic elements are generally addressed in an “apples by no means fall e-book evaluation”?

Typical analyses embody the narrative’s plot construction, character improvement, thematic depth, and total writing model. Examinations of pacing and narrative perspective are additionally steadily included.

Query 2: How does important reception affect the general notion of “apples by no means fall e-book evaluation”?

Important assessments, significantly these from respected sources, considerably form public opinion. Constructive critiques usually result in elevated readership, whereas destructive opinions can deter potential readers.

Query 3: What position do reader responses play in analyzing the affect of an “apples by no means fall e-book evaluation”?

Particular person reader reactions present beneficial insights into the novel’s emotional resonance and thematic relevance. Reader opinions, discovered on varied platforms, spotlight numerous interpretations and ranges of engagement with the textual content.

Query 4: In analyses, what key thematic components are steadily explored inside “apples by no means fall e-book evaluation”?

Recurring themes embody household dynamics, the complexities of long-term relationships, the misleading nature of appearances, and the enduring affect of the previous. These components usually kind the idea of important dialogue.

Query 5: How does narrative construction have an effect on analyses of “apples by no means fall e-book evaluation”?

The novel’s construction, characterised by a number of views and a non-linear timeline, prompts evaluations of its effectiveness in creating suspense and revealing character motivations. Critiques usually study how these structural selections improve or detract from the narrative’s readability.

Query 6: Why is pacing evaluation necessary inside an “apples by no means fall e-book evaluation”?

Evaluations of pacing take into account the novel’s tempo and the distribution of narrative occasions. Efficient pacing maintains reader engagement, whereas poor pacing can result in disinterest or frustration. Assessments usually deal with the novel’s potential to construct suspense and resolve plotlines at an acceptable charge.

In essence, an analysis of the novel encompasses an examination of each its structural and stylistic components, its reception by skilled critics, and the varied reactions of particular person readers. Every of those concerns contributes to a extra full understanding of its affect and significance.

The following part will synthesize the previous analyses, providing a concluding abstract of key insights.

Ideas for Analyzing Evaluative Texts of Apples By no means Fall

Efficient evaluation of critiques relating to Liane Moriarty’s novel necessitates a structured and knowledgeable method. The next ideas present steering for a complete evaluation of evaluations surrounding Apples By no means Fall.

Tip 1: Establish the Supply and Bias: Acknowledge the origin of the evaluative textual content. A proper literary evaluation will differ considerably from a reader’s weblog put up. Take into account potential biases, equivalent to pre-existing opinions in regards to the creator or style, which can affect the analysis.

Tip 2: Consider Objectivity in Plot Abstract: Decide the objectivity of the plot abstract supplied. Correct recounting of key plot factors is essential for establishing a shared understanding earlier than subjective evaluation. Be cautious of summaries which are overly interpretive or omit vital occasions.

Tip 3: Analyze Character Assessments: Scrutinize character analyses for depth and justification. Opinions ought to provide particular examples from the textual content to assist claims about character motivations, relationships, and improvement. Take into account whether or not interpretations align with textual proof and keep away from generalizations.

Tip 4: Look at Thematic Interpretations: Assess the validity of thematic interpretations introduced in evaluations. Establish the themes mentioned and take into account whether or not the reviewer provides credible proof from the novel to assist their claims. Consider the alignment between thematic interpretations and overarching narrative components.

Tip 5: Evaluate and Distinction Important Reception and Reader Response: Analyze the divergence between important acclaim and particular person reader reactions. Establish any vital discrepancies and try to grasp the components contributing to those variations. Skilled critics will present distinctive insights past private reactions.

Tip 6: Assess Analysis of Writing Type: Fastidiously consider claims relating to writing model. Assessments of pacing, dialogue, and descriptive language ought to be supported by particular textual examples. Decide whether or not the critique focuses on goal components of prose or just expresses subjective preferences.

Tip 7: Take into account the Evaluate’s Context: Acknowledge the historic and cultural context during which the evaluation was written. Evolving literary tendencies and societal values could affect the interpretation and analysis of Apples By no means Fall. Take into account how modern discussions of household dynamics or gender roles would possibly affect the evaluation.

The applying of those analytical methods ensures a extra knowledgeable and nuanced understanding of evaluative texts regarding the novel. By critically analyzing the content material and context of opinions, one can extra precisely assess the work’s literary deserves and lasting affect.

A concluding abstract synthesizing the core themes of Apples By no means Fall and its important evaluations will comply with.

Apples By no means Fall E book Evaluate

The previous examination has explored multifaceted dimensions of Apples By no means Fall e-book evaluation evaluation. An intensive understanding of the novel’s reception requires consideration of plot abstract accuracy, character evaluation depth, thematic interpretation validity, important response alignment with reader sentiment, and the target analysis of writing model. Moreover, context and potential bias inside evaluative texts should be acknowledged to assemble a balanced and knowledgeable perspective.

Continued engagement with literary criticism, coupled with particular person interpretation, fosters a richer understanding of each Apples By no means Fall and the broader panorama of up to date fiction. A sustained dedication to goal evaluation serves to refine appreciation for narrative complexity and authorial intent. Future discourse ought to discover the novel’s evolving relevance inside shifting cultural paradigms.

Leave a Comment